[Cooker] Re: [RPM] cooker main/release icu-4.0-1mdv2009.0

[Anssi Hannula-3]

Tomasz Pawel Gajc wrote:
> Name        : icu                          Relocations: (not relocatable)
> Version     : 4.0                               Vendor: Mandriva
> Release     : 1mdv2009.0                    Build Date: Fri Jul  4 15:07:22 2008
[...]
> Tomasz Pawel Gajc <tpg@...> 1:4.0-1mdv2009.0:
> + Revision: 231685
> - enable epoch :(
> - update to new version 4.0 (looks like the versioning has been broken, epoch needed ?)

I would've just made it "4.0.0" to avoid epoch.

(the previous one was "4.0.d01")

--
Anssi Hannula

[Tomasz Paweł Gajc]

Dnia 2008-07-04, o godz. 17:37:39
Anssi Hannula <anssi@...> napisał(a):

> Tomasz Pawel Gajc wrote:
> > Name        : icu                          Relocations: (not
> > relocatable) Version     : 4.0
> > Vendor: Mandriva Release     : 1mdv2009.0                    Build
> > Date: Fri Jul  4 15:07:22 2008
> [...]
> > Tomasz Pawel Gajc <tpg@...> 1:4.0-1mdv2009.0:
> > + Revision: 231685
> > - enable epoch :(
> > - update to new version 4.0 (looks like the versioning has been
> > broken, epoch needed ?)
>
> I would've just made it "4.0.0" to avoid epoch.
>
> (the previous one was "4.0.d01")
>

Prevois one was a "rc" looks like Funda didn't noticed this, and that's
why epoch was needed.

I'm against of using "fake" versions :\

--
Regards,
TPG - MandrivaLinux's contributor

www.mandriva.com
  _
 ( )
  X ascii ribbon campaign - against html e-mail
 / \ www.asciiribbon.org   - against proprietary attachments

[Adam Williamson-4]

On Fri, 2008-07-04 at 17:37 +0300, Anssi Hannula wrote:

> Tomasz Pawel Gajc wrote:
> > Name        : icu                          Relocations: (not relocatable)
> > Version     : 4.0                               Vendor: Mandriva
> > Release     : 1mdv2009.0                    Build Date: Fri Jul  4 15:07:22 2008
> [...]
> > Tomasz Pawel Gajc <tpg@...> 1:4.0-1mdv2009.0:
> > + Revision: 231685
> > - enable epoch :(
> > - update to new version 4.0 (looks like the versioning has been broken, epoch needed ?)
>
> I would've just made it "4.0.0" to avoid epoch.
>
> (the previous one was "4.0.d01")

d is bigger than 0, so 4.0.0 wouldn't have fixed it, I don't think.
4.0.d > 4.0.0, I think.
--
adamw

[Anssi Hannula-3]

Adam Williamson wrote:

> On Fri, 2008-07-04 at 17:37 +0300, Anssi Hannula wrote:
>> Tomasz Pawel Gajc wrote:
>>> Name        : icu                          Relocations: (not relocatable)
>>> Version     : 4.0                               Vendor: Mandriva
>>> Release     : 1mdv2009.0                    Build Date: Fri Jul  4 15:07:22 2008
>> [...]
>>> Tomasz Pawel Gajc <tpg@...> 1:4.0-1mdv2009.0:
>>> + Revision: 231685
>>> - enable epoch :(
>>> - update to new version 4.0 (looks like the versioning has been broken, epoch needed ?)
>> I would've just made it "4.0.0" to avoid epoch.
>>
>> (the previous one was "4.0.d01")
>
> d is bigger than 0, so 4.0.0 wouldn't have fixed it, I don't think.
> 4.0.d > 4.0.0, I think.

No, numbers > letters  in rpm versioning.

$ test-rpm-version.pl 4.0.0 4.0.d
4.0.0 > 4.0.d

--
Anssi Hannula