DNS poisoning?

View: New views
5 Messages — Rating Filter:   Alert me  

DNS poisoning?

by Bill Stout :: Rate this Message:

Reply to Author | View Threaded | Show Only this Message

Hello,

I'm working through an intermittent incoming email bounce problem I hope
someone can shed some light on.  A few major companies are reporting
intermittent bounces when sending email to us.

Someone forwarded a bounce message which contained the following
information:

  ... connect to mail.greenborder.com [216.52.7.214]: Connection timed
out ...

I do not have a host named 'mail.greenborder.com' in my DNS records.
The IP address is not a mail server, it's an Internap address.
http://www.dnsstuff.com/tools/whois.ch?ip=216.52.7.214

I tried to obtain help through the DNS experts at Network Solutions
through Customer Support; their Customer Support guys are _absolutely
clueless_ on how DNS works.  They keep referring me to 'the provider who
hosts my email service'.

My MX records are here:
http://www.dnsstuff.com/tools/lookup.ch?name=greenborder.com&type=MX
(Temporarily modified for troubleshooting purposes)

greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 USC1.MAILHOSTSXODE.NET. [Preference = 10]
greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 MAILGATE.greenborder.com. [Preference = 1]
greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 USP1.MAILHOSTSXODE.NET. [Preference = 5]
greenborder.com. NS IN 7200 NS31.WORLDNIC.com.
greenborder.com. NS IN 7200 NS32.WORLDNIC.com.
MAILGATE.greenborder.com. A IN 7200 66.123.15.52

Any help would be appreciated.

TIA,

Bill Stout

Re: DNS poisoning?

by fuzzyping :: Rate this Message:

Reply to Author | View Threaded | Show Only this Message

On Jan 26, 2007, at 10:23 PM, Bill Stout wrote:

> Hello,
>
> I'm working through an intermittent incoming email bounce problem I  
> hope
> someone can shed some light on.  A few major companies are reporting
> intermittent bounces when sending email to us.
>
> Someone forwarded a bounce message which contained the following
> information:
>
>   ... connect to mail.greenborder.com [216.52.7.214]: Connection timed
> out ...
>
> I do not have a host named 'mail.greenborder.com' in my DNS records.
> The IP address is not a mail server, it's an Internap address.
> http://www.dnsstuff.com/tools/whois.ch?ip=216.52.7.214
>
> I tried to obtain help through the DNS experts at Network Solutions
> through Customer Support; their Customer Support guys are _absolutely
> clueless_ on how DNS works.  They keep referring me to 'the  
> provider who
> hosts my email service'.
>
> My MX records are here:
> http://www.dnsstuff.com/tools/lookup.ch?name=greenborder.com&type=MX
> (Temporarily modified for troubleshooting purposes)
>
> greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 USC1.MAILHOSTSXODE.NET. [Preference = 10]
> greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 MAILGATE.greenborder.com. [Preference = 1]
> greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 USP1.MAILHOSTSXODE.NET. [Preference = 5]
> greenborder.com. NS IN 7200 NS31.WORLDNIC.com.
> greenborder.com. NS IN 7200 NS32.WORLDNIC.com.
> MAILGATE.greenborder.com. A IN 7200 66.123.15.52
>
> Any help would be appreciated.

Your records look fine on my end.  Both ns31 and ns32.worldnic.com  
return the following MX records:

greenborder.com.        7200    IN      MX      5  
USP1.MAILHOSTSXODE.NET.
greenborder.com.        7200    IN      MX      10  
USC1.MAILHOSTSXODE.NET.
greenborder.com.        7200    IN      MX      15  
MAILGATE.greenborder.com.

You need to find out which resolvers are returning the bad records to  
your senders.

HTH.

--
Jason Dixon
DixonGroup Consulting
http://www.dixongroup.net




Re: DNS poisoning?

by Hans-J. Ullrich :: Rate this Message:

Reply to Author | View Threaded | Show Only this Message

Am Samstag, 27. Januar 2007 04:23 schrieb Bill Stout:

> Hello,
>
> I'm working through an intermittent incoming email bounce problem I hope
> someone can shed some light on.  A few major companies are reporting
> intermittent bounces when sending email to us.
>
> Someone forwarded a bounce message which contained the following
> information:
>
>   ... connect to mail.greenborder.com [216.52.7.214]: Connection timed
> out ...
>
> I do not have a host named 'mail.greenborder.com' in my DNS records.
> The IP address is not a mail server, it's an Internap address.
> http://www.dnsstuff.com/tools/whois.ch?ip=216.52.7.214
>
> I tried to obtain help through the DNS experts at Network Solutions
> through Customer Support; their Customer Support guys are _absolutely
> clueless_ on how DNS works.  They keep referring me to 'the provider who
> hosts my email service'.
>
> My MX records are here:
> http://www.dnsstuff.com/tools/lookup.ch?name=greenborder.com&type=MX
> (Temporarily modified for troubleshooting purposes)
>
> greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 USC1.MAILHOSTSXODE.NET. [Preference = 10]
> greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 MAILGATE.greenborder.com. [Preference = 1]
> greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 USP1.MAILHOSTSXODE.NET. [Preference = 5]
> greenborder.com. NS IN 7200 NS31.WORLDNIC.com.
> greenborder.com. NS IN 7200 NS32.WORLDNIC.com.
> MAILGATE.greenborder.com. A IN 7200 66.123.15.52
>
> Any help would be appreciated.
>
> TIA,
>
> Bill Stout

Lokks like a spammer for me. Due to a mailserver is looking for a response
from a DNS, a spammer redirects it to his own Client (from which he wants to
spam). So tehere are to advantages: He can send with any address he wants to,
and sometimes it is faster.

Please correct me, if I am wrong.

regards

Hans
 

Re: DNS poisoning?

by Francois Yang :: Rate this Message:

Reply to Author | View Threaded | Show Only this Message

I wonder how many of those messages the person who sent you the
original bounce received.
I'm thinking what if they(spammer) sent out 1000s of messages with an
invalid From server and invalid users. The receiving server would try
to send the bounce message back 1000's of time and keep retrying.  So
it could be some kind of DOS against the person who sent you the
original bounce message.
just a thought.

On 1/29/07, Hans-J. Ullrich <hans.ullrich@...> wrote:

> Am Samstag, 27. Januar 2007 04:23 schrieb Bill Stout:
> > Hello,
> >
> > I'm working through an intermittent incoming email bounce problem I hope
> > someone can shed some light on.  A few major companies are reporting
> > intermittent bounces when sending email to us.
> >
> > Someone forwarded a bounce message which contained the following
> > information:
> >
> >   ... connect to mail.greenborder.com [216.52.7.214]: Connection timed
> > out ...
> >
> > I do not have a host named 'mail.greenborder.com' in my DNS records.
> > The IP address is not a mail server, it's an Internap address.
> > http://www.dnsstuff.com/tools/whois.ch?ip=216.52.7.214
> >
> > I tried to obtain help through the DNS experts at Network Solutions
> > through Customer Support; their Customer Support guys are _absolutely
> > clueless_ on how DNS works.  They keep referring me to 'the provider who
> > hosts my email service'.
> >
> > My MX records are here:
> > http://www.dnsstuff.com/tools/lookup.ch?name=greenborder.com&type=MX
> > (Temporarily modified for troubleshooting purposes)
> >
> > greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 USC1.MAILHOSTSXODE.NET. [Preference = 10]
> > greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 MAILGATE.greenborder.com. [Preference = 1]
> > greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 USP1.MAILHOSTSXODE.NET. [Preference = 5]
> > greenborder.com. NS IN 7200 NS31.WORLDNIC.com.
> > greenborder.com. NS IN 7200 NS32.WORLDNIC.com.
> > MAILGATE.greenborder.com. A IN 7200 66.123.15.52
> >
> > Any help would be appreciated.
> >
> > TIA,
> >
> > Bill Stout
>
> Lokks like a spammer for me. Due to a mailserver is looking for a response
> from a DNS, a spammer redirects it to his own Client (from which he wants to
> spam). So tehere are to advantages: He can send with any address he wants to,
> and sometimes it is faster.
>
> Please correct me, if I am wrong.
>
> regards
>
> Hans
>
>

RE: DNS poisoning? (Solved)

by Bill Stout :: Rate this Message:

Reply to Author | View Threaded | Show Only this Message

Hi guys,

Thanks for the feedback!

I originally posted to Firewalls on Friday and didn't see activity over
the weekend, so I posted to security-basics.  Paul daSilva pointed me to
the problem.

    $ whois internap.com
    [...]
    Domain servers in listed order:

       NS-A.PNAP.NET                64.94.123.4
       NS-B.PNAP.NET                64.94.123.36
       NS-C.PNAP.NET                64.95.61.4
       NS-D.PNAP.NET                64.95.61.36
    [...]


    $ nslookup
     > server 64.94.123.36
    Default server: 64.94.123.36
    Address: 64.94.123.36#53
     > mail.greenborder.com
    Server:         64.94.123.36
    Address:        64.94.123.36#53

    Name:   mail.greenborder.com
    Address: 216.52.7.214

The IP returned to the email client was also owned by Internap.
Internap claimed to be authoritive for my domain, and even had a few
fake records.  I'm unsure why this happened, but this stopped after an
email to their abuse and noc email addresses.  Their DNS servers no
longer return hostnames or claim authority.  What I did manage to
capture before the change was a set of false records:

mail.greenborder.com False Address:  216.52.7.214
www.greenborder.com False Address:  216.52.7.212
ftp.greenborder.com False Address:  216.52.7.210

If this was malicious, the next question is how long, what login
information did these systems capture, and what email may have been
intercepted.

I see the changes, but Internap has not replied to my email (dns
problems? ;) ).

Bill Stout
GreenBorder


-----Original Message-----
From: listbounce@... [mailto:listbounce@...]
On Behalf Of Bill Stout
Sent: Friday, January 26, 2007 7:24 PM
To: firewalls@...
Subject: DNS poisoning?

Hello,

I'm working through an intermittent incoming email bounce problem I hope
someone can shed some light on.  A few major companies are reporting
intermittent bounces when sending email to us.

Someone forwarded a bounce message which contained the following
information:

  ... connect to mail.greenborder.com [216.52.7.214]: Connection timed
out ...

I do not have a host named 'mail.greenborder.com' in my DNS records.
The IP address is not a mail server, it's an Internap address.
http://www.dnsstuff.com/tools/whois.ch?ip=216.52.7.214

I tried to obtain help through the DNS experts at Network Solutions
through Customer Support; their Customer Support guys are _absolutely
clueless_ on how DNS works.  They keep referring me to 'the provider who
hosts my email service'.

My MX records are here:
http://www.dnsstuff.com/tools/lookup.ch?name=greenborder.com&type=MX
(Temporarily modified for troubleshooting purposes)

greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 USC1.MAILHOSTSXODE.NET. [Preference = 10]
greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 MAILGATE.greenborder.com. [Preference = 1]
greenborder.com. MX IN 7200 USP1.MAILHOSTSXODE.NET. [Preference = 5]
greenborder.com. NS IN 7200 NS31.WORLDNIC.com.
greenborder.com. NS IN 7200 NS32.WORLDNIC.com.
MAILGATE.greenborder.com. A IN 7200 66.123.15.52

Any help would be appreciated.

TIA,

Bill Stout