Modern mail archive layout using mhonarc

View: New views
5 Messages — Rating Filter:   Alert me  

Parent Message unknown Modern mail archive layout using mhonarc

by Ngieen Siao-Mak :: Rate this Message:

Reply to Author | View Threaded | Show Only this Message


Did anyone try to layout a mail archive with features and layout that are similar to Google Groups? Is it possible? What does it required? If possible and not freely available, would anyone be interested in pa paid project?

thanks!


Re: Modern mail archive layout using mhonarc

by Earl Hood :: Rate this Message:

Reply to Author | View Threaded | Show Only this Message

On February 23, 2009 at 11:54, Ngieen Siao-Mak wrote:

> Did anyone try to layout a mail archive with features and layout that are
> similar to Google Groups? Is it possible? What does it required?

Not sure if this will help you, but years ago, I did a custom job for
Cisco to support the generation of a "discussion" pages.  These were
pages that contain all the messages of a thread.  The nature of
the contract allowed me to do the work under the GPL, so I can
redistribute it.

I was hoping to modify the work and repackage it for a more general
audience, but never did it.  However, for those interested, your
can download the custom script at the following location:

  http://www.mhonarc.org/cisco/

v0.2.3 was the last version done.  Documentation is provided
describing how it works.  The mha-cisco script is a good example
of utilizing the simple API mhonarc provides to extend it functionality.

BTW, the core, venerable code base of mhonarc makes certain things
difficult, especially functionality that implies a more dynamic nature.
And scalability is a problem for large archives.  Mhonarc is a good
example of a program that has out-grown its original intentions :)

Work-arounds do exist to work with scalability issues, but they
can vary depending on the operating model one wants to achieve.

I've considered numerous times to redesign and re-implement mhonarc,
but there has been little motivation to do so.  The work will take
a non-trivial amount of time, and I have other priorities.

--ewh


Re: Modern mail archive layout using mhonarc

by Ngieen Siao-Mak :: Rate this Message:

Reply to Author | View Threaded | Show Only this Message

Thank you Earl;


Not sure if this will help you, but years ago, I did a custom job for
Cisco to support the generation of a "discussion" pages.  

Is there a working demo of the layout?
 
 
I was hoping to modify the work and repackage it for a more general
audience, but never did it.  However, for those interested, your
can download the custom script at the following location:

 

BTW, the core, venerable code base of mhonarc makes certain things
difficult, especially functionality that implies a more dynamic nature.
And scalability is a problem for large archives.  Mhonarc is a good
example of a program that has out-grown its original intentions :)

 
Mailing lists and webarchive are still *hot* . the dynamics are better than the forums as we visit the users (via email) rather than waiting for the users to login to the forums. I am sure that with a modern utility to archive the mailing list more will be using it rather than changing to web boards... I would pay for a good mail list archive utility.
 

I've considered numerous times to redesign and re-implement mhonarc,
but there has been little motivation to do so.  The work will take
a non-trivial amount of time, and I have other priorities.

Make it a commercial version! I am sure $$ is a good motivation! ;_))


Re: Modern mail archive layout using mhonarc

by Dave Dewey :: Rate this Message:

Reply to Author | View Threaded | Show Only this Message

Quoting Ngieen Siao-Mak (ngieen@...):

>
>    Make it a commercial version! I am sure $$ is a good motivation! ;_))

I would support this also.  Mhonarc is a critical part of my user
community, but it's getting creaky.  It definitely would be worth
paying for to have something with better integration into other
platforms and has a better search interface.


RE: Modern mail archive layout using mhonarc

by Dave Stragand :: Rate this Message:

Reply to Author | View Threaded | Show Only this Message

As they say, "me three".

-----Original Message-----
From: owner-mhonarc-users@...
[mailto:owner-mhonarc-users@...] On Behalf Of Dave Dewey
Sent: Thursday, February 26, 2009 1:33 PM
To: mhonarc-users@...
Subject: Re: Modern mail archive layout using mhonarc

Quoting Ngieen Siao-Mak (ngieen@...):

>
>    Make it a commercial version! I am sure $$ is a good motivation!
;_))

I would support this also.  Mhonarc is a critical part of my user
community, but it's getting creaky.  It definitely would be worth
paying for to have something with better integration into other
platforms and has a better search interface.