« Return to Thread: [mb-style] Lets put GettingRidOfFeaturingArtistStyle to the vote.
RE: [mb-style] Lets put GettingRidOfFeaturingArtistSty
by Cristov Russell
::
Rate this Message:
> OK folks, it's been a couple of weeks since anyone has added
> anything to
> http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/GettingRidOfFeaturingArtistStyle
>
> Because I'm fed up with 'mo' dicking around with my
> moderations, I'd like to try putting this to a (completely
> non-binding) vote, using the Apache Lazy Concensus rules.
>
> Reply to this thread, and simply say +1 if you agree, -1 if
> you disagree, or a number in between if you're opinion is in
> between (see bottom of this mail for examples). Also say if
> you're a member of the Style Council, or just a mailinglist
> participant. Next Saturday (12th), I'll tot-up the votes.
>
> PROPOSAL: We change FeaturingArtistStyle to read: "When two
> or more artists collaborate on a track or release, file the
> track/release under the primary artist, and then add
> "performed on" relationships to the secondary artists. If no
> artist can be considered secondary, create a new artist in
> the form 'Artist 1 & Artist 2' and add "collaborated on"
> relationships to the artists."
>
> I vote +1, but I'm not a Style Council member.
>
> Rod.
>
> -----
> Expressing Votes: +1, 0, -1, and Fractions
>
> The voting process in Apache may seem more than a little
> weird if you've never encountered it before. Votes are
> represented as numbers between -1 and +1, with '-1' meaning
> 'no' and '+1' meaning 'yes.'
>
> The in-between values are indicative of how strongly the
> voting individual feels. Here are some examples of fractional
> votes and ways in which they might be intended and interpreted:
>
> * +0: 'I don't feel strongly about it, but I'm okey with this.'
> * -0: 'I won't get in the way, but I'd rather we didn't do this.'
> * -0.5: 'I don't like this idea, but I can't find any
> rational justification for my feelings.'
> * ++1: 'Wow! I like this! Let's do it!'
> * -0.9: 'I really don't like this, but I'm not going to
> stand in the way if everyone else wants to go ahead with it.'
> * +0.9: 'This is a cool idea and i like it, but I don't
> have time/the skills necessary to help out.'
>
> -- http://www.apache.org/foundation/voting.html
> --
> :: Rod Begbie :: http://groovymother.com/ ::
> anything to
> http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/GettingRidOfFeaturingArtistStyle
>
> Because I'm fed up with 'mo' dicking around with my
> moderations, I'd like to try putting this to a (completely
> non-binding) vote, using the Apache Lazy Concensus rules.
>
> Reply to this thread, and simply say +1 if you agree, -1 if
> you disagree, or a number in between if you're opinion is in
> between (see bottom of this mail for examples). Also say if
> you're a member of the Style Council, or just a mailinglist
> participant. Next Saturday (12th), I'll tot-up the votes.
>
> PROPOSAL: We change FeaturingArtistStyle to read: "When two
> or more artists collaborate on a track or release, file the
> track/release under the primary artist, and then add
> "performed on" relationships to the secondary artists. If no
> artist can be considered secondary, create a new artist in
> the form 'Artist 1 & Artist 2' and add "collaborated on"
> relationships to the artists."
>
> I vote +1, but I'm not a Style Council member.
>
> Rod.
>
> -----
> Expressing Votes: +1, 0, -1, and Fractions
>
> The voting process in Apache may seem more than a little
> weird if you've never encountered it before. Votes are
> represented as numbers between -1 and +1, with '-1' meaning
> 'no' and '+1' meaning 'yes.'
>
> The in-between values are indicative of how strongly the
> voting individual feels. Here are some examples of fractional
> votes and ways in which they might be intended and interpreted:
>
> * +0: 'I don't feel strongly about it, but I'm okey with this.'
> * -0: 'I won't get in the way, but I'd rather we didn't do this.'
> * -0.5: 'I don't like this idea, but I can't find any
> rational justification for my feelings.'
> * ++1: 'Wow! I like this! Let's do it!'
> * -0.9: 'I really don't like this, but I'm not going to
> stand in the way if everyone else wants to go ahead with it.'
> * +0.9: 'This is a cool idea and i like it, but I don't
> have time/the skills necessary to help out.'
>
> -- http://www.apache.org/foundation/voting.html
> --
> :: Rod Begbie :: http://groovymother.com/ ::
Sorry I haven't gotten back to everyone on a process yet; I've been taking
care of my mom post surgery. I have a few things from work to catch up on
but hopefully will have something soon.
Rod I don't think this voting system will work. Mainly because there are
multiple solutions proposed and your system seems to be predicated on a
single change. I do think it's an interesting idea to allow for "levels" of
feeling but it doesn't seem applicable.
Also, if a consensus can be reached with the Style Ministers involved a vote
shouldn't be necessary. There still needs to be a process and control to the
implementation of changes as well which I will include in my proposal.
________________________________
Cristov (wolfsong)
Stay close young hobbits! They say there's a great sorceress lives in these
woods. An elf-witch of terrible power. All who look upon her fall
_______________________________________________
Musicbrainz-style mailing list
Musicbrainz-style@...
http://lists.musicbrainz.org/mailman/listinfo/musicbrainz-style
« Return to Thread: [mb-style] Lets put GettingRidOfFeaturingArtistStyle to the vote.
| Free embeddable forum powered by Nabble | Forum Help |
