« Return to Thread: [VOTE] Maven 2.2.0 (Fourth Attempt)

Re: [VOTE] Maven 2.2.0 (Fourth Attempt)

by Benjamin Bentmann :: Rate this Message:

Reply to Author | View in Thread

John Casey wrote:

> I've backed out all version-expression transformation, including the
> code that was added in 2.1.0-*.

Yup, got that.

> So, 4167 isn't fixed to my knowledge.

I basically don't follow your comment on MNG-3538:
 > This issue duplicates the reports in MNG-3057 and MNG-4167

To recap, we're talking about

MNG-3057 - properties not expanded in generated POMs when building A/B/C
nested projects

MNG-4167 - version-expression transformation interferes with plugins
like GPG

 From the descriptions, these look like two related but still different
issues. The version-expression transformation is no longer interferring
with the GPG Plugin (because it was entirely removed), isn't it? The GPG
Plugin being back working with Maven 2.2.0, I consider MNG-4167 to be
fixed in 2.2.0, matching the justification to close MGPG-14.

So to me, interpolating artifact-related properties is the unresolved
issue, not the negative side effect our initial attempt had on the GPG
Plugin.

Anyway, no biggie, just wanted to bring your attention to it, might
simply be a language problem on my side.


Benjamin

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscribe@...
For additional commands, e-mail: dev-help@...

 « Return to Thread: [VOTE] Maven 2.2.0 (Fourth Attempt)