WARNING: This server is unstable and will be retired in the next days.
If you want to keep this forum available, please request immediately a migration
on the Nabble Support forum.
Forums that don't receive any migration request will be deleted forever.
Joey Hess, le Sun 13 May 2012 20:39:20 -0400, a écrit :
> Neil Williams wrote:
> > "supporting only the smaller/lighter desktop environments" is exactly
> > what comes out of accepting that the first two options just won't be
> > acceptable. Changing compression is only putting off the inevitable.
> > There's *no* reason to think that GNOME or KDE are going to get back
> > below the 1 CD limit at the next Debian stable release.
> > I'd support XFCE4 as the default Graphical Desktop Environment and
> > possibly putting GNOME (and KDE) as alternative options.
> > That way, GNOME and KDE (as explicit options) should only show up in
> > the list if using a medium which can provide that amount of packages.
> While I have started putting XFCE on systems I install for family etc,
> I am not sure if it's really suitable yes to be the default desktop
> environment. There are probably quite a lot of fit and finish issues.
> Here are two major problems:
> * There does not seem to be much accessability support in XFCE. With
> gnome, we have a fully accessible system from the login manager on.
> Accessability improvements are on the XFCE roadmap; this should
> improve with time. http://wiki.xfce.org/releng/4.10/roadmap/accessibility
Well, things are not so clear. With gnome, we *used* to have a fully
accessible system from the login manager on. The gnome3 transition
has brought a lot of regressions, and using XFCE as a base for an
accessible desktop makes a lot of sense; at least as much it does with
gnome3. Quoting the abovementioned page:
“but there are a lot of parts of the interface (custom widgets, buttons
without label) that are hard to access with a screen reader.”
I haven't tried myself, but gnome3 most probably introduced
non-accessible custom widgets, buttons without labels, etc. For
instance, the alt-F2 widget, used a lot by blind people, is currently
> I hope that we can avoid the CD size forcing the desktop for at least
> one more release. Note that we had the same trouble the last two
> releases, and managed to make it fit in the end both times.
It looked to me like it was harder and harder each time.