Remarks and questions about XQ Update Facility test suite

[Xavier Franc]

Hello all,

- Apparently there are some issues with the files in directory
   xquery-update-10-test-suite/ReportingResults of  the XQUF test suite.
 It seems that these files are simple copies of the standard XQuery test
suite rather then what is mentioned on the web site (XQUTSReport.html,
XQUTSReportSimple.html, XQUTSResult.xsd etc).

- it would be nice to have a zip distribution of the XQUF TS.

- Is there a plan to publish a result page like for XQuery ?
- Or to integrate this as an optional module of the standard test suite ?

Cheers
Xavier

[Andrew Eisenberg-2]

public-xqts-comments-request@... wrote on 04/17/2008 01:29:57 PM:

> - Apparently there are some issues with the files in directory
>    xquery-update-10-test-suite/ReportingResults of  the XQUF test suite.
>  It seems that these files are simple copies of the standard XQuery test
> suite rather then what is mentioned on the web site (XQUTSReport.html,
> XQUTSReportSimple.html, XQUTSResult.xsd etc).

I'm not sure what you mean. The files in this directory were updated about a month ago.
 
> - it would be nice to have a zip distribution of the XQUF TS.

I'll ask Jonathan to comment on this.
 
> - Is there a plan to publish a result page like for XQuery ?

You'll find our early results in http://dev.w3.org/2007/xquery-update-10-test-suite/results/.

> - Or to integrate this as an optional module of the standard test suite ?

We're keeping these results separate for now. This might change when we get further along with XQuery 1.1.


--------------------
Andrew Eisenberg
IBM
4 Technology Park Drive
Westford, MA  01886

andrew.eisenberg@...
Phone: [phone]    Fax: [phone]

[Jonathan Robie-2]

Andrew Eisenberg wrote:
>
> > - it would be nice to have a zip distribution of the XQUF TS.
>
> I'll ask Jonathan to comment on this.

First off, Xavier, my apologies, I just check and I see that I failed to
respond to an earlier inquiry from you.

So far, I've been resisting suggestions to create a zip distribution
because most developers are able to use source code control systems,
which are a better way to develop a test suite collaboratively, and I
don't want to have to worry about whether a zip distribution is out of
sync with the source code repository. If enough people give me a good
reason that the source code control system does not work for them, I may
change my mind, but I'm reluctant to provide a zip without a really good
reason.

> > - Is there a plan to publish a result page like for XQuery ?
>
> You'll find our early results in
> http://dev.w3.org/2007/xquery-update-10-test-suite/results/.

And your results would be very welcome.

Jonathan

[Xavier Franc]

Hello Jonathan,

my apologies too for the delay in responding to you, this is not
retalation :-)
I was just waiting to be ready to provide results for the new version
Qizx 2.1
which supports the XQuery Update Facility 1.0.
Pleas find attached these results.

Concerning my previous remarks/questions, I completely understands your
reasons.

best regards
Xavier

Jonathan Robie wrote:

>
> Andrew Eisenberg wrote:
>>
>> > - it would be nice to have a zip distribution of the XQUF TS.
>>
>> I'll ask Jonathan to comment on this.
>
> First off, Xavier, my apologies, I just check and I see that I failed
> to respond to an earlier inquiry from you.
>
> So far, I've been resisting suggestions to create a zip distribution
> because most developers are able to use source code control systems,
> which are a better way to develop a test suite collaboratively, and I
> don't want to have to worry about whether a zip distribution is out of
> sync with the source code repository. If enough people give me a good
> reason that the source code control system does not work for them, I
> may change my mind, but I'm reluctant to provide a zip without a
> really good reason.
>
>> > - Is there a plan to publish a result page like for XQuery ?
>>
>> You'll find our early results in
>> http://dev.w3.org/2007/xquery-update-10-test-suite/results/.
>
> And your results would be very welcome.
>
> Jonathan
>
>
>

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<test-suite-result
   xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2005/02/query-test-XQTSResult'
   xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance">

   <implementation
      name='Qizx'
      version='Qizx 2.1'
      anonymous-result-column="false">

      <organization
         name='XMLmind'
         website="http://www.xmlmind.com/qizx/"
         anonymous="false" />

      <submittor
         name="Xavier Franc"
         email="[see web site]" />

      <description>
         <p>Qizx is an embeddable XML database engine written in Java.</p>
      </description>

      <implementation-defined-items>

      <implementation-defined-item name="implicitTimezone" spec="XQuery"
            value="Can be set through the API. Default is local timezone.">
           <description last-mod="2005-04-04">The implicit timezone.</description>
         </implementation-defined-item>

      </implementation-defined-items>

      <features>
         <feature
            name='Minimum Conformance'
            supported='true' />
      </features>

      <context-properties>
         <context-property
            name="Default collation"
            context-type='static'
            value="codepoint." />
      <context-property name="Statically known namespaces" context-type="static"
      value="prefix x for extension functions, can be augmented through the API and by the Java binding mechanism."/>
      </context-properties>

   </implementation>

   <syntax>XQuery</syntax>

   <test-run dateRun='Tue May 20 19:45:59 GMT+01:00 2008'>
      <test-suite version="0.7" />
      <transformation>
         <p> Some results have been slightly changed because of whitespace issues.</p>
      </transformation>
      <comparison>
         <p>Comparisons as recommended by the guidelines.
         Whitespace is stripped before comparison in most cases,
         except when 'preserve' is present in the query.</p>
      </comparison>
    </test-run>

   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-01' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-02' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-03' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-04' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-05' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-06' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-07' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-08' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-09' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-010' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-011' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-012' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-013' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-014' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-015' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-016' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-017' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-018' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-019' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-020' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-021' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-022' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-023' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-024' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-025' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-026' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-027' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-028' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-029' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-030' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-031' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-032' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-033' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-034' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-035' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-036' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-037' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-038' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-039' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-040' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-041' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-042' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-043' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-044' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-045' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-046' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-047' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-048' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-049' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-insert-expr-050' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-delete-expr-01' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-delete-expr-02' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-delete-expr-03' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-delete-expr-04' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-delete-expr-05' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-delete-expr-06' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-delete-expr-07' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-delete-expr-08' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-delete-expr-09' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-delete-expr-010' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-delete-expr-011' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-delete-expr-012' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-01' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-02' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-03' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-04' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-05' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-06' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-07' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-08' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-09' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-010' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-011' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-012' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-013' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-014' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-015' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-016' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-017' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-018' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-019' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-020' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-021' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-022' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-023' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-024' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-025' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-026' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-replace-expr-027' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-01' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-02' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-03' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-04' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-05' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-06' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-07' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-08' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-09' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-010' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-011' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-012' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-013' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-014' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-015' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-016' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-017' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-018' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-019' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-rename-expr-020' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-01' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-02' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-03' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-04' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-05' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-06' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-07' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-08' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-09' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-010' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-011' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-012' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-013' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-014' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-015' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-016' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-017' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-018' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-019' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-020' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-021' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-022' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-023' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-024' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-025' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-026' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-027' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-028' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-029' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-030' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-transform-expr-031' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-01' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-02' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-03' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-04' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-05' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-06' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-07' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-08' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-09' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-010' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-011' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-012' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-013' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-014' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-015' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-016' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-017' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-018' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-019' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-020' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-021' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-flwor-expr-022' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-01' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-02' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-03' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-04' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-05' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-06' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-07' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-08' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-09' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-010' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-011' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-012' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-013' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-014' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-015' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-016' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-017' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-018' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-019' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-020' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-021' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-022' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-023' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-024' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-025' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-026' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-027' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-028' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-029' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-030' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-031' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-032' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-033' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-034' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-typeswitch-expr-035' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-01' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-02' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-03' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-04' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-05' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-06' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-07' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-08' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-09' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-010' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-011' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-012' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-013' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-014' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-015' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-016' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-017' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-018' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-019' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-020' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-021' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-022' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-023' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-024' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-025' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-026' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-027' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-028' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-029' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-030' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-031' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-032' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-033' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-034' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-conditional-expr-035' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-01' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-02' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-03' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-04' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-05' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-06' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-07' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-08' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-09' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-010' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-011' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-012' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-013' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-014' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-015' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-016' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-017' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-018' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-019' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-020' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-021' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-022' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-023' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-024' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-025' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-026' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-027' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-028' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-029' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-030' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-031' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-032' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-033' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-034' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-comma-expr-035' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-declaration-01' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-declaration-02' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-declaration-03' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-declaration-04' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-declaration-05' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-declaration-06' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-declaration-07' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-declaration-08' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-declaration-09' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-declaration-010' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-declaration-011' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-declaration-012' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-declaration-013' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-declaration-014' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-call-01' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-call-02' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-call-03' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-call-04' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-call-05' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-function-call-06' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-01' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-02' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-03' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-04' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-05' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-06' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-07' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-08' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-09' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-010' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-011' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-012' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-013' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-014' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-015' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-016' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-017' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-018' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-019' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-020' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-021' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-022' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-023' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-024' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-025' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-26' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-027' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-028' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-029' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-030' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-031' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='id-other-expr-032' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-01' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-02' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-03' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-04' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-05' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-06' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-07' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-08' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-09' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-10' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-11' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-12' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-13' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-14' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-15' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-16' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-17' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-18' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-19' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-20' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-21' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-22' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-23' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-24' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-25' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-26' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-27' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-28' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-29' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-30' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-31' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-32' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-33' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-34' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-35' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-36' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-37' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-38' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-39' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-40' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-41' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-42' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-43' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-44' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-45' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-46' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-47' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-48' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-49' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-50' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-51' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-52' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-53' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-54' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-55' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-56' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-57' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-58' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-59' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='statictyp-xqupd-60' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='relational-data-q1' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='relational-data-q2' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='relational-data-q3' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='relational-data-q4' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='relational-data-q5-1' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='relational-data-q5-2' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='relational-data-q6-1' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='relational-data-q6-2' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='relational-data-q7' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='relational-data-q8' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='relational-data-q9' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='address-book-q1' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='soap-q1' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='namespaces-q1' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='parts-q1' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='parts-q2' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='parts-q3-1' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='parts-q3-2' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='parts-q4-1' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='parts-q4-2' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='parts-q6' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='nil-q1' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ins-001' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ins-002' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ins-003' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ins-004' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ins-005' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ins-006' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ins-007' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ins-008' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ins-009' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ins-010' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ins-011' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ins-012' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ins-013' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ins-014' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-del-001' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-del-002' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-del-003' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-del-004' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-del-005' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ren-001' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ren-002' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ren-003' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ren-004' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ren-005' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-ren-006' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='valskip-repnode-001' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-repnode-002' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-repnode-003' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-repnode-004' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-repnode-005' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valskip-repnode-006' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-del-001' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-del-002' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-del-003' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-del-004' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-ins-001' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-ins-002' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-ins-003' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-ins-004' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-ins-005' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-ins-006' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-ins-007' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-ren-001' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-ren-002' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-ren-003' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-repnode-001' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-repnode-002' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='valstrict-repnode-003' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valtrans-ins-001' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='valtrans-ins-002' result='fail' />
   <test-case name='valtrans-ins-003' result='pass' />
   <test-case name='put-001' result='fail' />
</test-suite-result>

[Jonathan Robie-2]

Excellent - thanks for sending these Xavier! As you know, results like
these really help us make the case that our specification should
progress. I assume we can put these results on our public test results page?

Jonathan

Xavier Franc wrote:

> Hello Jonathan,
>
> my apologies too for the delay in responding to you, this is not
> retalation :-)
> I was just waiting to be ready to provide results for the new version
> Qizx 2.1
> which supports the XQuery Update Facility 1.0.
> Pleas find attached these results.
>
> Concerning my previous remarks/questions, I completely understands
> your reasons.
>
> best regards
> Xavier
>
> Jonathan Robie wrote:
>>
>> Andrew Eisenberg wrote:
>>>
>>> > - it would be nice to have a zip distribution of the XQUF TS.
>>>
>>> I'll ask Jonathan to comment on this.
>>
>> First off, Xavier, my apologies, I just check and I see that I failed
>> to respond to an earlier inquiry from you.
>>
>> So far, I've been resisting suggestions to create a zip distribution
>> because most developers are able to use source code control systems,
>> which are a better way to develop a test suite collaboratively, and I
>> don't want to have to worry about whether a zip distribution is out
>> of sync with the source code repository. If enough people give me a
>> good reason that the source code control system does not work for
>> them, I may change my mind, but I'm reluctant to provide a zip
>> without a really good reason.
>>
>>> > - Is there a plan to publish a result page like for XQuery ?
>>>
>>> You'll find our early results in
>>> http://dev.w3.org/2007/xquery-update-10-test-suite/results/.
>>
>> And your results would be very welcome.
>>
>> Jonathan
>>
>>
>>
>

[Xavier Franc]

I forgot to mention a new XQuery Update tutorial that XMLmind has just
published
http://www.xmlmind.com/_tutorials/XQueryUpdate/index.html
(I am going to write to Liam for announcing it on the XQuery page)

You are most welcome to comment about this tutorial and signal any
mistake of inaccuracy
or obscurity, including in my English.

Cheers
Xavier


Jonathan Robie wrote:

> Excellent - thanks for sending these Xavier! As you know, results like
> these really help us make the case that our specification should
> progress. I assume we can put these results on our public test results
> page?
>
> Jonathan
>
> Xavier Franc wrote:
>> Hello Jonathan,
>>
>> my apologies too for the delay in responding to you, this is not
>> retalation :-)
>> I was just waiting to be ready to provide results for the new version
>> Qizx 2.1
>> which supports the XQuery Update Facility 1.0.
>> Pleas find attached these results.
>>
>> Concerning my previous remarks/questions, I completely understands
>> your reasons.
>>
>> best regards
>> Xavier
>>
>> Jonathan Robie wrote:
>>>
>>> Andrew Eisenberg wrote:
>>>>
>>>> > - it would be nice to have a zip distribution of the XQUF TS.
>>>>
>>>> I'll ask Jonathan to comment on this.
>>>
>>> First off, Xavier, my apologies, I just check and I see that I
>>> failed to respond to an earlier inquiry from you.
>>>
>>> So far, I've been resisting suggestions to create a zip distribution
>>> because most developers are able to use source code control systems,
>>> which are a better way to develop a test suite collaboratively, and
>>> I don't want to have to worry about whether a zip distribution is
>>> out of sync with the source code repository. If enough people give
>>> me a good reason that the source code control system does not work
>>> for them, I may change my mind, but I'm reluctant to provide a zip
>>> without a really good reason.
>>>
>>>> > - Is there a plan to publish a result page like for XQuery ?
>>>>
>>>> You'll find our early results in
>>>> http://dev.w3.org/2007/xquery-update-10-test-suite/results/.
>>>
>>> And your results would be very welcome.
>>>
>>> Jonathan
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>
>
>
>