Stuck Notes
|
View:
New views
3 Messages
—
Rating Filter:
Alert me
|
 |
Stuck Notes
by Jeremy Sawruk
::
Rate this Message:
Some parts of this message have been removed.
Learn more about Nabble's security policy.
I have tried using both Note Off events and Note On events with velocity = 0, but the notes remain stuck. Please see the attached MIDI file. I am running Timidity 2.11.3 on Windows Vista. The same problem occurs on Windows XP. I suspect the problem is one of the following: 1) The MIDI data is not correct, but in some non-obvious way that I have not been able to identify 2) There is a problem with the soundfont. I didn't create the soundfont, so I cannot guarantee that it is correct 3) There is a problem with this port to Windows. I haven't been able to try it on Linux yet. Any help would be extremely appreciated. J. Sawruk ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Sponsored by: SourceForge.net Community Choice Awards: VOTE NOW! Studies have shown that voting for your favorite open source project, along with a healthy diet, reduces your potential for chronic lameness and boredom. Vote Now at http://www.sourceforge.net/community/cca08 _______________________________________________ Timidity-talk mailing list Timidity-talk@... https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/timidity-talk |
|
|
Re: Stuck Notes
by Johan Vromans
::
Rate this Message:
Jeremy Sawruk <lobachevski@...> writes:
> I suspect the problem is one of the following: 1) The MIDI data is not > correct, but in some non-obvious way that I have not been able to > identify 2) There is a problem with the soundfont. I didn't create the > soundfont, so I cannot guarantee that it is correct 3) There is a > problem with this port to Windows. I haven't been able to try it on > Linux yet. On Linux, I see / hear nothing abnormal. The note events start with a note_on/off of note pitch 0, very unusual... -- Johan MIDI::Opus->new({ 'format' => 1, 'ticks' => 480, 'tracks' => [ # 1 tracks... # Track #0 ... MIDI::Track->new({ 'type' => 'MTrk', 'events' => [ # 104 events. ['patch_change', 0, 0, 1], # 0 001-01-00-00 Channel 0, patch = Bright Acoustic ['patch_change', 0, 2, 1], # 0 001-01-00-00 Channel 2, patch = Bright Acoustic ['time_signature', 0, 4, 2, 24, 8], # 0 001-01-00-00 Time = 4/4, Click = 24, NoteQ = 8 ['key_signature', 0, 0, 0], # 0 001-01-00-00 Key = C ['set_tempo', 0, 600000], # 0 001-01-00-00 Tempo: q = 100 ['note_on', 0, 1, 0, 1], # 0 001-01-00-00 On: C-2 ['note_off', 2462, 1, 0, 1], # 2462 002-02-02-04 Off: C-2 ['note_on', 0, 0, 73, 100], # 2462 002-02-02-04 On: C#4 ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 2462 002-02-02-04 On: C#4 ['note_off', 150, 0, 73, 0], # 2612 002-02-07-04 Off: C#4 ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 2612 002-02-07-04 Off: C#4 ['note_on', 1, 0, 70, 100], # 2613 002-02-07-06 On: A#3 ['note_on', 0, 2, 70, 94], # 2613 002-02-07-06 On: A#3 ['note_off', 147, 0, 70, 0], # 2760 002-02-12-00 Off: A#3 ['note_off', 0, 2, 70, 0], # 2760 002-02-12-00 Off: A#3 ['note_on', 9, 0, 70, 100], # 2769 002-02-12-18 On: A#3 ['note_on', 0, 2, 70, 94], # 2769 002-02-12-18 On: A#3 ['note_off', 141, 0, 70, 0], # 2910 002-03-01-00 Off: A#3 ['note_off', 0, 2, 70, 0], # 2910 002-03-01-00 Off: A#3 ['note_on', 14, 0, 82, 100], # 2924 002-03-01-28 On: A#4 ['note_on', 0, 2, 82, 94], # 2924 002-03-01-28 On: A#4 ['note_off', 154, 0, 82, 0], # 3078 002-03-06-36 Off: A#4 ['note_off', 0, 2, 82, 0], # 3078 002-03-06-36 Off: A#4 ['note_on', 1, 0, 73, 100], # 3079 002-03-06-38 On: C#4 ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 3079 002-03-06-38 On: C#4 ['note_off', 71, 0, 73, 0], # 3150 002-03-09-00 Off: C#4 ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 3150 002-03-09-00 Off: C#4 ['note_on', 227, 0, 77, 100], # 3377 002-04-00-34 On: F4 ['note_on', 0, 2, 77, 94], # 3377 002-04-00-34 On: F4 ['note_off', 342, 0, 77, 0], # 3719 002-04-11-58 Off: F4 ['note_off', 0, 2, 77, 0], # 3719 002-04-11-58 Off: F4 ['note_on', 1231, 0, 72, 100], # 4950 003-03-05-00 On: C4 ['note_on', 0, 2, 72, 94], # 4950 003-03-05-00 On: C4 ['note_off', 135, 0, 72, 0], # 5085 003-03-09-30 Off: C4 ['note_off', 0, 2, 72, 0], # 5085 003-03-09-30 Off: C4 ['note_on', 16, 0, 67, 100], # 5101 003-03-10-02 On: G3 ['note_on', 0, 2, 67, 94], # 5101 003-03-10-02 On: G3 ['note_off', 145, 0, 67, 0], # 5246 003-03-14-52 Off: G3 ['note_off', 0, 2, 67, 0], # 5246 003-03-14-52 Off: G3 ['note_on', 8, 0, 73, 100], # 5254 003-03-15-08 On: C#4 ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 5254 003-03-15-08 On: C#4 ['note_off', 96, 0, 73, 0], # 5350 003-04-02-20 Off: C#4 ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 5350 003-04-02-20 Off: C#4 ['note_on', 60, 0, 70, 100], # 5410 003-04-04-20 On: A#3 ['note_on', 0, 2, 70, 94], # 5410 003-04-04-20 On: A#3 ['note_off', 142, 0, 70, 0], # 5552 003-04-09-04 Off: A#3 ['note_off', 0, 2, 70, 0], # 5552 003-04-09-04 Off: A#3 ['note_on', 8, 0, 73, 100], # 5560 003-04-09-20 On: C#4 ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 5560 003-04-09-20 On: C#4 ['note_off', 78, 0, 73, 0], # 5638 003-04-11-56 Off: C#4 ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 5638 003-04-11-56 Off: C#4 ['note_on', 199, 0, 85, 100], # 5837 004-01-02-34 On: C#5 ['note_on', 0, 2, 85, 94], # 5837 004-01-02-34 On: C#5 ['note_off', 273, 0, 85, 0], # 6110 004-01-11-40 Off: C#5 ['note_off', 0, 2, 85, 0], # 6110 004-01-11-40 Off: C#5 ['note_on', 1313, 0, 73, 100], # 7423 004-04-07-26 On: C#4 ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 7423 004-04-07-26 On: C#4 ['note_off', 131, 0, 73, 0], # 7554 004-04-11-48 Off: C#4 ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 7554 004-04-11-48 Off: C#4 ['note_on', 14, 0, 70, 100], # 7568 004-04-12-16 On: A#3 ['note_on', 0, 2, 70, 94], # 7568 004-04-12-16 On: A#3 ['note_off', 142, 0, 70, 0], # 7710 005-01-01-00 Off: A#3 ['note_off', 0, 2, 70, 0], # 7710 005-01-01-00 Off: A#3 ['note_on', 2, 0, 70, 100], # 7712 005-01-01-04 On: A#3 ['note_on', 0, 2, 70, 94], # 7712 005-01-01-04 On: A#3 ['note_off', 140, 0, 70, 0], # 7852 005-01-05-44 Off: A#3 ['note_off', 0, 2, 70, 0], # 7852 005-01-05-44 Off: A#3 ['note_on', 6, 0, 82, 100], # 7858 005-01-05-56 On: A#4 ['note_on', 0, 2, 82, 94], # 7858 005-01-05-56 On: A#4 ['note_off', 144, 0, 82, 0], # 8002 005-01-10-44 Off: A#4 ['note_off', 0, 2, 82, 0], # 8002 005-01-10-44 Off: A#4 ['note_on', 6, 0, 73, 100], # 8008 005-01-10-56 On: C#4 ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 8008 005-01-10-56 On: C#4 ['note_off', 92, 0, 73, 0], # 8100 005-01-14-00 Off: C#4 ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 8100 005-01-14-00 Off: C#4 ['note_on', 191, 0, 77, 100], # 8291 005-02-04-22 On: F4 ['note_on', 0, 2, 77, 94], # 8291 005-02-04-22 On: F4 ['note_off', 433, 0, 77, 0], # 8724 005-03-02-48 Off: F4 ['note_off', 0, 2, 77, 0], # 8724 005-03-02-48 Off: F4 ['note_on', 1140, 0, 72, 100], # 9864 006-01-08-48 On: C4 ['note_on', 0, 2, 72, 94], # 9864 006-01-08-48 On: C4 ['note_off', 156, 0, 72, 0], # 10020 006-01-14-00 Off: C4 ['note_off', 0, 2, 72, 0], # 10020 006-01-14-00 Off: C4 ['note_on', 2, 0, 67, 100], # 10022 006-01-14-04 On: G3 ['note_on', 0, 2, 67, 94], # 10022 006-01-14-04 On: G3 ['note_off', 145, 0, 67, 0], # 10167 006-02-02-54 Off: G3 ['note_off', 0, 2, 67, 0], # 10167 006-02-02-54 Off: G3 ['note_on', 5, 0, 73, 100], # 10172 006-02-03-04 On: C#4 ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 10172 006-02-03-04 On: C#4 ['note_off', 136, 0, 73, 0], # 10308 006-02-07-36 Off: C#4 ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 10308 006-02-07-36 Off: C#4 ['note_on', 28, 0, 70, 100], # 10336 006-02-08-32 On: A#3 ['note_on', 0, 2, 70, 94], # 10336 006-02-08-32 On: A#3 ['note_off', 148, 0, 70, 0], # 10484 006-02-13-28 Off: A#3 ['note_off', 0, 2, 70, 0], # 10484 006-02-13-28 Off: A#3 ['note_on', 6, 0, 73, 100], # 10490 006-02-13-40 On: C#4 ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 10490 006-02-13-40 On: C#4 ['note_off', 60, 0, 73, 0], # 10550 006-02-15-40 Off: C#4 ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 10550 006-02-15-40 Off: C#4 ['note_on', 221, 0, 85, 100], # 10771 006-03-07-02 On: C#5 ['note_on', 0, 2, 85, 94], # 10771 006-03-07-02 On: C#5 ['note_off', 374, 0, 85, 0], # 11145 006-04-03-30 Off: C#5 ['note_off', 0, 2, 85, 0], # 11145 006-04-03-30 Off: C#5 ['text_event', 1, ''], # 11146 006-04-03-32 ] }), ] }); ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Sponsored by: SourceForge.net Community Choice Awards: VOTE NOW! Studies have shown that voting for your favorite open source project, along with a healthy diet, reduces your potential for chronic lameness and boredom. Vote Now at http://www.sourceforge.net/community/cca08 _______________________________________________ Timidity-talk mailing list Timidity-talk@... https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/timidity-talk |
|
|
Re: Stuck Notes
by Bobby McNulty-6
::
Rate this Message:
Same on Windows with Media Player.
Plus, sounds like one of my songs. Bobby ----- Original Message ----- From: "Johan Vromans" <jvromans@...> To: <timidity-talk@...> Sent: Saturday, July 12, 2008 8:43 AM Subject: Re: [timidity-talk] Stuck Notes > Jeremy Sawruk <lobachevski@...> writes: > >> I suspect the problem is one of the following: 1) The MIDI data is not >> correct, but in some non-obvious way that I have not been able to >> identify 2) There is a problem with the soundfont. I didn't create the >> soundfont, so I cannot guarantee that it is correct 3) There is a >> problem with this port to Windows. I haven't been able to try it on >> Linux yet. > > On Linux, I see / hear nothing abnormal. > The note events start with a note_on/off of note pitch 0, very > unusual... > > -- Johan > > MIDI::Opus->new({ > 'format' => 1, > 'ticks' => 480, > 'tracks' => [ # 1 tracks... > > # Track #0 ... > MIDI::Track->new({ > 'type' => 'MTrk', > 'events' => [ # 104 events. > ['patch_change', 0, 0, 1], # 0 001-01-00-00 > Channel 0, patch = Bright Acoustic > ['patch_change', 0, 2, 1], # 0 001-01-00-00 > Channel 2, patch = Bright Acoustic > ['time_signature', 0, 4, 2, 24, 8], # 0 001-01-00-00 > Time = 4/4, Click = 24, NoteQ = 8 > ['key_signature', 0, 0, 0], # 0 001-01-00-00 > Key = C > ['set_tempo', 0, 600000], # 0 001-01-00-00 > Tempo: q = 100 > ['note_on', 0, 1, 0, 1], # 0 001-01-00-00 > On: C-2 > ['note_off', 2462, 1, 0, 1], # 2462 002-02-02-04 > Off: C-2 > ['note_on', 0, 0, 73, 100], # 2462 002-02-02-04 > On: C#4 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 2462 002-02-02-04 > On: C#4 > ['note_off', 150, 0, 73, 0], # 2612 002-02-07-04 > Off: C#4 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 2612 002-02-07-04 > Off: C#4 > ['note_on', 1, 0, 70, 100], # 2613 002-02-07-06 > On: A#3 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 70, 94], # 2613 002-02-07-06 > On: A#3 > ['note_off', 147, 0, 70, 0], # 2760 002-02-12-00 > Off: A#3 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 70, 0], # 2760 002-02-12-00 > Off: A#3 > ['note_on', 9, 0, 70, 100], # 2769 002-02-12-18 > On: A#3 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 70, 94], # 2769 002-02-12-18 > On: A#3 > ['note_off', 141, 0, 70, 0], # 2910 002-03-01-00 > Off: A#3 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 70, 0], # 2910 002-03-01-00 > Off: A#3 > ['note_on', 14, 0, 82, 100], # 2924 002-03-01-28 > On: A#4 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 82, 94], # 2924 002-03-01-28 > On: A#4 > ['note_off', 154, 0, 82, 0], # 3078 002-03-06-36 > Off: A#4 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 82, 0], # 3078 002-03-06-36 > Off: A#4 > ['note_on', 1, 0, 73, 100], # 3079 002-03-06-38 > On: C#4 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 3079 002-03-06-38 > On: C#4 > ['note_off', 71, 0, 73, 0], # 3150 002-03-09-00 > Off: C#4 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 3150 002-03-09-00 > Off: C#4 > ['note_on', 227, 0, 77, 100], # 3377 002-04-00-34 > On: F4 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 77, 94], # 3377 002-04-00-34 > On: F4 > ['note_off', 342, 0, 77, 0], # 3719 002-04-11-58 > Off: F4 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 77, 0], # 3719 002-04-11-58 > Off: F4 > ['note_on', 1231, 0, 72, 100], # 4950 003-03-05-00 > On: C4 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 72, 94], # 4950 003-03-05-00 > On: C4 > ['note_off', 135, 0, 72, 0], # 5085 003-03-09-30 > Off: C4 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 72, 0], # 5085 003-03-09-30 > Off: C4 > ['note_on', 16, 0, 67, 100], # 5101 003-03-10-02 > On: G3 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 67, 94], # 5101 003-03-10-02 > On: G3 > ['note_off', 145, 0, 67, 0], # 5246 003-03-14-52 > Off: G3 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 67, 0], # 5246 003-03-14-52 > Off: G3 > ['note_on', 8, 0, 73, 100], # 5254 003-03-15-08 > On: C#4 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 5254 003-03-15-08 > On: C#4 > ['note_off', 96, 0, 73, 0], # 5350 003-04-02-20 > Off: C#4 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 5350 003-04-02-20 > Off: C#4 > ['note_on', 60, 0, 70, 100], # 5410 003-04-04-20 > On: A#3 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 70, 94], # 5410 003-04-04-20 > On: A#3 > ['note_off', 142, 0, 70, 0], # 5552 003-04-09-04 > Off: A#3 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 70, 0], # 5552 003-04-09-04 > Off: A#3 > ['note_on', 8, 0, 73, 100], # 5560 003-04-09-20 > On: C#4 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 5560 003-04-09-20 > On: C#4 > ['note_off', 78, 0, 73, 0], # 5638 003-04-11-56 > Off: C#4 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 5638 003-04-11-56 > Off: C#4 > ['note_on', 199, 0, 85, 100], # 5837 004-01-02-34 > On: C#5 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 85, 94], # 5837 004-01-02-34 > On: C#5 > ['note_off', 273, 0, 85, 0], # 6110 004-01-11-40 > Off: C#5 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 85, 0], # 6110 004-01-11-40 > Off: C#5 > ['note_on', 1313, 0, 73, 100], # 7423 004-04-07-26 > On: C#4 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 7423 004-04-07-26 > On: C#4 > ['note_off', 131, 0, 73, 0], # 7554 004-04-11-48 > Off: C#4 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 7554 004-04-11-48 > Off: C#4 > ['note_on', 14, 0, 70, 100], # 7568 004-04-12-16 > On: A#3 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 70, 94], # 7568 004-04-12-16 > On: A#3 > ['note_off', 142, 0, 70, 0], # 7710 005-01-01-00 > Off: A#3 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 70, 0], # 7710 005-01-01-00 > Off: A#3 > ['note_on', 2, 0, 70, 100], # 7712 005-01-01-04 > On: A#3 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 70, 94], # 7712 005-01-01-04 > On: A#3 > ['note_off', 140, 0, 70, 0], # 7852 005-01-05-44 > Off: A#3 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 70, 0], # 7852 005-01-05-44 > Off: A#3 > ['note_on', 6, 0, 82, 100], # 7858 005-01-05-56 > On: A#4 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 82, 94], # 7858 005-01-05-56 > On: A#4 > ['note_off', 144, 0, 82, 0], # 8002 005-01-10-44 > Off: A#4 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 82, 0], # 8002 005-01-10-44 > Off: A#4 > ['note_on', 6, 0, 73, 100], # 8008 005-01-10-56 > On: C#4 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 8008 005-01-10-56 > On: C#4 > ['note_off', 92, 0, 73, 0], # 8100 005-01-14-00 > Off: C#4 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 8100 005-01-14-00 > Off: C#4 > ['note_on', 191, 0, 77, 100], # 8291 005-02-04-22 > On: F4 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 77, 94], # 8291 005-02-04-22 > On: F4 > ['note_off', 433, 0, 77, 0], # 8724 005-03-02-48 > Off: F4 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 77, 0], # 8724 005-03-02-48 > Off: F4 > ['note_on', 1140, 0, 72, 100], # 9864 006-01-08-48 > On: C4 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 72, 94], # 9864 006-01-08-48 > On: C4 > ['note_off', 156, 0, 72, 0], # 10020 006-01-14-00 > Off: C4 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 72, 0], # 10020 006-01-14-00 > Off: C4 > ['note_on', 2, 0, 67, 100], # 10022 006-01-14-04 > On: G3 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 67, 94], # 10022 006-01-14-04 > On: G3 > ['note_off', 145, 0, 67, 0], # 10167 006-02-02-54 > Off: G3 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 67, 0], # 10167 006-02-02-54 > Off: G3 > ['note_on', 5, 0, 73, 100], # 10172 006-02-03-04 > On: C#4 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 10172 006-02-03-04 > On: C#4 > ['note_off', 136, 0, 73, 0], # 10308 006-02-07-36 > Off: C#4 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 10308 006-02-07-36 > Off: C#4 > ['note_on', 28, 0, 70, 100], # 10336 006-02-08-32 > On: A#3 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 70, 94], # 10336 006-02-08-32 > On: A#3 > ['note_off', 148, 0, 70, 0], # 10484 006-02-13-28 > Off: A#3 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 70, 0], # 10484 006-02-13-28 > Off: A#3 > ['note_on', 6, 0, 73, 100], # 10490 006-02-13-40 > On: C#4 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 73, 94], # 10490 006-02-13-40 > On: C#4 > ['note_off', 60, 0, 73, 0], # 10550 006-02-15-40 > Off: C#4 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 73, 0], # 10550 006-02-15-40 > Off: C#4 > ['note_on', 221, 0, 85, 100], # 10771 006-03-07-02 > On: C#5 > ['note_on', 0, 2, 85, 94], # 10771 006-03-07-02 > On: C#5 > ['note_off', 374, 0, 85, 0], # 11145 006-04-03-30 > Off: C#5 > ['note_off', 0, 2, 85, 0], # 11145 006-04-03-30 > Off: C#5 > ['text_event', 1, ''], # 11146 006-04-03-32 > ] > }), > > ] > }); > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------- > Sponsored by: SourceForge.net Community Choice Awards: VOTE NOW! > Studies have shown that voting for your favorite open source project, > along with a healthy diet, reduces your potential for chronic lameness > and boredom. Vote Now at http://www.sourceforge.net/community/cca08 > _______________________________________________ > Timidity-talk mailing list > Timidity-talk@... > https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/timidity-talk ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Sponsored by: SourceForge.net Community Choice Awards: VOTE NOW! Studies have shown that voting for your favorite open source project, along with a healthy diet, reduces your potential for chronic lameness and boredom. Vote Now at http://www.sourceforge.net/community/cca08 _______________________________________________ Timidity-talk mailing list Timidity-talk@... https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/timidity-talk |
test.mid (650 bytes) | Free embeddable forum powered by Nabble | Forum Help |
