Very old repositories

[Faker Moatamri]

Hi Tom & all,
In the repositories page we have repositories that remained untouched
from one day to 2 years!
http://code.nsnam.org/?sort=lastchange
Should we remove let's say repositories that hasn't been touched for 1
year or more with owner's permission if any?
Best regards
Faker Moatamri

[Andrey Mazo]

> In the repositories page we have repositories that remained untouched
> from one day to 2 years!
> http://code.nsnam.org/?sort=lastchange
> Should we remove let's say repositories that hasn't been touched for 1
> year or more with owner's permission if any?
I'd like to remove the following kinds of repositories:
1) "*-old" repositories
2) all repositories, already merged into ns-3-dev
3) all ns-3{rc,RC}* repositories


--
Andrey Mazo.

[Faker Moatamri]

Andrey Mazo wrote:

>> In the repositories page we have repositories that remained untouched
>> from one day to 2 years!
>> http://code.nsnam.org/?sort=lastchange
>> Should we remove let's say repositories that hasn't been touched for 1
>> year or more with owner's permission if any?
> I'd like to remove the following kinds of repositories:
> 1) "*-old" repositories
> 2) all repositories, already merged into ns-3-dev
> 3) all ns-3{rc,RC}* repositories
>
>

+1 from me if we are sure that the removed repositories are useless.
Others?

[Mirko Banchi]

Il giorno 22/ott/09, alle ore 16:12, Faker Moatamri ha scritto:

> Andrey Mazo wrote:
>>> In the repositories page we have repositories that remained  
>>> untouched
>>> from one day to 2 years!
>>> http://code.nsnam.org/?sort=lastchange
>>> Should we remove let's say repositories that hasn't been touched  
>>> for 1
>>> year or more with owner's permission if any?
>> I'd like to remove the following kinds of repositories:
>> 1) "*-old" repositories
>> 2) all repositories, already merged into ns-3-dev
>> 3) all ns-3{rc,RC}* repositories
>>
>>
> +1 from me if we are sure that the removed repositories are useless.
> Others?

+1 from me

Mirko

--
Mirko Banchi

e-mail:    mk.banchi@...
e-mail:    mk.banchi@...
id-jabber: mk.banchi@...

PGP key fingerprint:

308F BFB1 4E67 2522 C88E
DC69 7631 52ED 32A5 6456

[Tom Henderson-2]

Faker Moatamri wrote:
> Hi Tom & all,
> In the repositories page we have repositories that remained untouched
> from one day to 2 years!
> http://code.nsnam.org/?sort=lastchange
> Should we remove let's say repositories that hasn't been touched for 1
> year or more with owner's permission if any?

Faker,
I would be fine with your suggested cleanup and Andrey's subsequent
suggestion.  I created a contributed/ folder on the web server to store
some of the older repositories that may have some archival value:

http://www.nsnam.org/wiki/index.php/Contributed_Code#Archived_repositories

but I did not remove those repositories from code.nsnam.org.

Developers should feel free to make use of this archive directory as
they see fit; in general, it seems like 12 months is enough dormancy to
move a repo to an archive.

- Tom

[Faker Moatamri]

Tom Henderson wrote:

> Faker Moatamri wrote:
>> Hi Tom & all,
>> In the repositories page we have repositories that remained untouched
>> from one day to 2 years!
>> http://code.nsnam.org/?sort=lastchange
>> Should we remove let's say repositories that hasn't been touched for
>> 1 year or more with owner's permission if any?
>
> Faker,
> I would be fine with your suggested cleanup and Andrey's subsequent
> suggestion.  I created a contributed/ folder on the web server to
> store some of the older repositories that may have some archival value:
>
> http://www.nsnam.org/wiki/index.php/Contributed_Code#Archived_repositories 
>
>
> but I did not remove those repositories from code.nsnam.org.
>

Hi Tom and all,
As a first step to cleaning, I will remove the following repositories
which are more that 1 year old on Wednesday October 28th at 10 am (GMT+1):

raj/docs/wns2-ns-3-tutorial
<http://code.nsnam.org/raj/docs/wns2-ns-3-tutorial/>                    
            WNS2 2008 Tutorial Files<raj.b@...>
raj/ns-3-dev-http <http://code.nsnam.org/raj/ns-3-dev-http/>            
                                    toy http model<raj.b@...>
gjc/ns-3-wifi-scanning <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-wifi-scanning/>  
                                    ns-3 experimental WiFi
scanning<gjcarneiro@...> <gjc@...>
ns-3.2 <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3.2/>                                
                                ns-3.2 release<ns-developers@...>
ns-3.2-ref-traces <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3.2-ref-traces/>            
                                    reference traces for
ns-3.2<ns-developers@...>
gjc/ns-3-virtual-netdevice
<http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-virtual-netdevice/>                    
            unknownunknown
lj/quagga-porting <http://code.nsnam.org/lj/quagga-porting/>            
                                  quagga porting<liujatp@...>
lj/ns-3-netlink <http://code.nsnam.org/lj/ns-3-netlink/>                
                                   ns3 netlink sockets<liujatp@...>
fw/ns-3-nsc-old <http://code.nsnam.org/fw/ns-3-nsc-old/>                
                               ns-3 Network Simulation Cradle
portFlorian Westphal <fw@...>
mathieu/ns-3-nam <http://code.nsnam.org/mathieu/ns-3-nam/>            
                               unknownunknown
ns-3-sigcomm <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3-sigcomm/>                    
                              Sigcomm demo tree<tomh@...>
pfeifer/ns-3-para <http://code.nsnam.org/pfeifer/ns-3-para/>            
                                   ns-3 parallelized branch<hagen@...>
ns-3.1 <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3.1/>                                
                                ns-3.1 relese<ns-developers@...>
ns-3.1-ref-traces <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3.1-ref-traces/>            
                                    reference traces for
ns-3.1<ns-developers@...>
pfeifer/ns-3-para-mpi <http://code.nsnam.org/pfeifer/ns-3-para-mpi/>    
                                    MPI infrastructure<hagen@...>
docs <http://code.nsnam.org/docs/>                                    
                              s3 Documentation<ns-developers@...>
mathieu/ns-3-yans <http://code.nsnam.org/mathieu/ns-3-yans/>            
                                 unknownunknown

Next step we will remove RC* repositories and Old repositories.
If anyone has any objection, please tell us as soon as possible.
Best regards
Faker Moatamri
> Developers should feel free to make use of this archive directory as
> they see fit; in general, it seems like 12 months is enough dormancy
> to move a repo to an archive.
>
> - Tom

[Faker Moatamri]

Faker Moatamri wrote:

> Hi Tom and all,
> As a first step to cleaning, I will remove the following repositories
> which are more that 1 year old on Wednesday October 28th at 10 am
> (GMT+1):
>
> raj/docs/wns2-ns-3-tutorial
> <http://code.nsnam.org/raj/docs/wns2-ns-3-tutorial/>                    
>            WNS2 2008 Tutorial Files<raj.b@...>
> raj/ns-3-dev-http
> <http://code.nsnam.org/raj/ns-3-dev-http/>            
>                                    toy http model<raj.b@...>
> gjc/ns-3-wifi-scanning
> <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-wifi-scanning/>  
>                                    ns-3 experimental WiFi
> scanning<gjcarneiro@...> <gjc@...>
> ns-3.2 <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3.2/>                                
>                                ns-3.2 release<ns-developers@...>
> ns-3.2-ref-traces
> <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3.2-ref-traces/>            
>                                    reference traces for
> ns-3.2<ns-developers@...>
> gjc/ns-3-virtual-netdevice
> <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-virtual-netdevice/>                    
>            unknownunknown
> lj/quagga-porting
> <http://code.nsnam.org/lj/quagga-porting/>            
>                                  quagga porting<liujatp@...>
> lj/ns-3-netlink
> <http://code.nsnam.org/lj/ns-3-netlink/>                
>                                   ns3 netlink sockets<liujatp@...>
> fw/ns-3-nsc-old
> <http://code.nsnam.org/fw/ns-3-nsc-old/>                
>                               ns-3 Network Simulation Cradle
> portFlorian Westphal <fw@...>
> mathieu/ns-3-nam <http://code.nsnam.org/mathieu/ns-3-nam/>            
>                               unknownunknown
> ns-3-sigcomm <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3-sigcomm/>                    
>                              Sigcomm demo tree<tomh@...>
> pfeifer/ns-3-para
> <http://code.nsnam.org/pfeifer/ns-3-para/>            
>                                   ns-3 parallelized
> branch<hagen@...>
> ns-3.1 <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3.1/>                                
>                                ns-3.1 relese<ns-developers@...>
> ns-3.1-ref-traces
> <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3.1-ref-traces/>            
>                                    reference traces for
> ns-3.1<ns-developers@...>
> pfeifer/ns-3-para-mpi
> <http://code.nsnam.org/pfeifer/ns-3-para-mpi/>    
>                                    MPI infrastructure<hagen@...>
> docs <http://code.nsnam.org/docs/>                                    
>                              s3 Documentation<ns-developers@...>
> mathieu/ns-3-yans
> <http://code.nsnam.org/mathieu/ns-3-yans/>            
>                                 unknownunknown
>

Hi Tom and All,
This has been done today as mentioned.
> Next step we will remove RC* repositories and Old repositories.
>
Here is the new list of repositories to be removed on Friday October
30th at 10am (GMT+1):
ns-3.6-RC4                                            ns-.6-RC3
release    <ns-developers@...>    8 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC4-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.6-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    8 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC3                                            ns-.6-RC3
release    <ns-developers@...>    12 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC3-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.6-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    12 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC2                                            ns-.6-RC2
release    <ns-developers@...>    13 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC2-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.6-RC2 release    <ns-developers@...>    13 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC1                                            ns-.6-RC1
release    <ns-developers@...>    2 weeks ago  
ns-3.6-RC1-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.6-RC1 release    <ns-developers@...>    2 weeks ago      
iamine/ns-3-wimax-to_be_released     wimax module for ns-3 to be merged
with the main ns-3-dev tree    <amine.ismail@...>    2
months ago  
ns-3-wimax-to_be_released_old2        wimax module for ns-3 to be merged
with the main ns-3-dev tree    <amine.ismail@...>    2
months ago  
ns-3-wimax-to_be_released_old          wimax module for ns-3 to be
merged with the main ns-3-dev tree    <amine.ismail@...>    
2 months ago  
ns-3-wimax-dev-old                             unknown    unknown    3
months ago  
ns-3.4-RC3                                            ns-3.4-RC3
release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC3-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.4-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC2                                            ns-3.4-RC2
release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC2-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.4-RC2 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC1                                            ns-3.4-RC1
release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC1-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.4-RC1 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
craigdo/ns-3-test-patches-old                Mercurial Queues patches
repository backup for ns-3 testing development    
<craigdo@...>    2 months ago
ns-3-wimax-old                                     ns-3 wimax
development tree    <amine.ismail@...>    10 months ago  
mathieu/ns-3-simu-old                          unknown    unknown    10
months ago  
vincent/ns-3-ipv6-1st                            NS-3 simulator with
IPv6 support (first chunk).    unknown    11 months ago

*For the vincent/ns-3-ipv6-1st I need green light to remove it, does it
need to be archived?
*If you have any objection to remove any of the above repositories,
please tell me as soon as possible.
Best regards
Faker Moatamri

[Sébastien Vincent]

Faker Moatamri a écrit :

> Faker Moatamri wrote:
>> Hi Tom and all,
>> As a first step to cleaning, I will remove the following repositories
>> which are more that 1 year old on Wednesday October 28th at 10 am
>> (GMT+1):
>>
>> raj/docs/wns2-ns-3-tutorial
>> <http://code.nsnam.org/raj/docs/wns2-ns-3-tutorial/>                    
>>            WNS2 2008 Tutorial Files<raj.b@...>
>> raj/ns-3-dev-http
>> <http://code.nsnam.org/raj/ns-3-dev-http/>            
>>                                    toy http model<raj.b@...>
>> gjc/ns-3-wifi-scanning
>> <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-wifi-scanning/>  
>>                                    ns-3 experimental WiFi
>> scanning<gjcarneiro@...> <gjc@...>
>> ns-3.2
>> <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3.2/>                                
>>                                ns-3.2 release<ns-developers@...>
>> ns-3.2-ref-traces
>> <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3.2-ref-traces/>            
>>                                    reference traces for
>> ns-3.2<ns-developers@...>
>> gjc/ns-3-virtual-netdevice
>> <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-virtual-netdevice/>                    
>>            unknownunknown
>> lj/quagga-porting
>> <http://code.nsnam.org/lj/quagga-porting/>            
>>                                  quagga porting<liujatp@...>
>> lj/ns-3-netlink
>> <http://code.nsnam.org/lj/ns-3-netlink/>                
>>                                   ns3 netlink sockets<liujatp@...>
>> fw/ns-3-nsc-old
>> <http://code.nsnam.org/fw/ns-3-nsc-old/>                
>>                               ns-3 Network Simulation Cradle
>> portFlorian Westphal <fw@...>
>> mathieu/ns-3-nam <http://code.nsnam.org/mathieu/ns-3-nam/>            
>>                               unknownunknown
>> ns-3-sigcomm <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3-sigcomm/>                    
>>                              Sigcomm demo tree<tomh@...>
>> pfeifer/ns-3-para
>> <http://code.nsnam.org/pfeifer/ns-3-para/>            
>>                                   ns-3 parallelized
>> branch<hagen@...>
>> ns-3.1 <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3.1/>                                
>>                                ns-3.1 relese<ns-developers@...>
>> ns-3.1-ref-traces
>> <http://code.nsnam.org/ns-3.1-ref-traces/>            
>>                                    reference traces for
>> ns-3.1<ns-developers@...>
>> pfeifer/ns-3-para-mpi
>> <http://code.nsnam.org/pfeifer/ns-3-para-mpi/>    
>>                                    MPI infrastructure<hagen@...>
>> docs
>> <http://code.nsnam.org/docs/>                                    
>>                              s3 Documentation<ns-developers@...>
>> mathieu/ns-3-yans
>> <http://code.nsnam.org/mathieu/ns-3-yans/>            
>>                                 unknownunknown
>>
> Hi Tom and All,
> This has been done today as mentioned.
>> Next step we will remove RC* repositories and Old repositories.
>>
> Here is the new list of repositories to be removed on Friday October
> 30th at 10am (GMT+1):
> ns-3.6-RC4                                            ns-.6-RC3
> release    <ns-developers@...>    8 days ago  
> ns-3.6-RC4-ref-traces                            reference traces for
> ns-3.6-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    8 days ago  
> ns-3.6-RC3                                            ns-.6-RC3
> release    <ns-developers@...>    12 days ago  
> ns-3.6-RC3-ref-traces                            reference traces for
> ns-3.6-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    12 days ago  
> ns-3.6-RC2                                            ns-.6-RC2
> release    <ns-developers@...>    13 days ago  
> ns-3.6-RC2-ref-traces                            reference traces for
> ns-3.6-RC2 release    <ns-developers@...>    13 days ago  
> ns-3.6-RC1                                            ns-.6-RC1
> release    <ns-developers@...>    2 weeks ago  
> ns-3.6-RC1-ref-traces                            reference traces for
> ns-3.6-RC1 release    <ns-developers@...>    2 weeks ago      
> iamine/ns-3-wimax-to_be_released     wimax module for ns-3 to be
> merged with the main ns-3-dev tree    
> <amine.ismail@...>    2 months ago  
> ns-3-wimax-to_be_released_old2        wimax module for ns-3 to be
> merged with the main ns-3-dev tree    
> <amine.ismail@...>    2 months ago  
> ns-3-wimax-to_be_released_old          wimax module for ns-3 to be
> merged with the main ns-3-dev tree    
> <amine.ismail@...>    2 months ago  
> ns-3-wimax-dev-old                             unknown    unknown    3
> months ago   ns-3.4-RC3                                            
> ns-3.4-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
> ns-3.4-RC3-ref-traces                            reference traces for
> ns-3.4-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
> ns-3.4-RC2                                            ns-3.4-RC2
> release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
> ns-3.4-RC2-ref-traces                            reference traces for
> ns-3.4-RC2 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
> ns-3.4-RC1                                            ns-3.4-RC1
> release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
> ns-3.4-RC1-ref-traces                            reference traces for
> ns-3.4-RC1 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
> craigdo/ns-3-test-patches-old                Mercurial Queues patches
> repository backup for ns-3 testing development    
> <craigdo@...>    2 months ago
> ns-3-wimax-old                                     ns-3 wimax
> development tree    <amine.ismail@...>    10 months ago  
> mathieu/ns-3-simu-old                          unknown    unknown    
> 10 months ago   vincent/ns-3-ipv6-1st                            NS-3
> simulator with IPv6 support (first chunk).    unknown    11 months ago
>
> *For the vincent/ns-3-ipv6-1st I need green light to remove it, does
> it need to be archived?

You can remove it as code has been merged in ns-3-dev now.

> *If you have any objection to remove any of the above repositories,
> please tell me as soon as possible.
> Best regards
> Faker Moatamri
>
>

[Mathieu Lacage]

On Wed, 2009-10-28 at 10:51 +0100, Faker Moatamri wrote:
> mathieu/ns-3-simu-old                          unknown    unknown
> 10 months ago    
> If you have any objection to remove any of the above repositories,
> please tell me as soon as possible.

I am pretty careful in removing uneeded repositories from mathieu/* so,
if something is still in there, it means that it has not been merged in
another repository yet which means that I would prefer to leave it
there.

Mathieu

[Faker Moatamri]

Mathieu Lacage wrote:

> On Wed, 2009-10-28 at 10:51 +0100, Faker Moatamri wrote:
>  
>> mathieu/ns-3-simu-old                          unknown    unknown
>> 10 months ago    
>> If you have any objection to remove any of the above repositories,
>> please tell me as soon as possible.
>>    
>
> I am pretty careful in removing uneeded repositories from mathieu/* so,
> if something is still in there, it means that it has not been merged in
> another repository yet which means that I would prefer to leave it
> there.
>
>  

Ok we will keep your repository. Should we archive it? It remained
untouched for nearly one year...

Anyone else has any objection on the removal of repositories from this list:
ns-3.6-RC4                                            ns-.6-RC3
release    <ns-developers@...>    8 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC4-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.6-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    8 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC3                                            ns-.6-RC3
release    <ns-developers@...>    12 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC3-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.6-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    12 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC2                                            ns-.6-RC2
release    <ns-developers@...>    13 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC2-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.6-RC2 release    <ns-developers@...>    13 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC1                                            ns-.6-RC1
release    <ns-developers@...>    2 weeks ago  
ns-3.6-RC1-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.6-RC1 release    <ns-developers@...>    2 weeks ago      
iamine/ns-3-wimax-to_be_released     wimax module for ns-3 to be merged
with the main ns-3-dev tree    <amine.ismail@...>    2
months ago  
ns-3-wimax-to_be_released_old2        wimax module for ns-3 to be merged
with the main ns-3-dev tree    <amine.ismail@...>    2
months ago  
ns-3-wimax-to_be_released_old          wimax module for ns-3 to be
merged with the main ns-3-dev tree    <amine.ismail@...>    
2 months ago  
ns-3-wimax-dev-old                             unknown    unknown    3
months ago  
ns-3.4-RC3                                            ns-3.4-RC3
release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC3-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.4-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC2                                            ns-3.4-RC2
release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC2-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.4-RC2 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC1                                            ns-3.4-RC1
release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC1-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.4-RC1 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
craigdo/ns-3-test-patches-old                Mercurial Queues patches
repository backup for ns-3 testing development    
<craigdo@...>    2 months ago
ns-3-wimax-old                                     ns-3 wimax
development tree    <amine.ismail@...>    10 months ago  
vincent/ns-3-ipv6-1st                            NS-3 simulator with
IPv6 support (first chunk).    unknown    11 months ago
> Mathieu
>
>  
Best regards
Faker Moatamri

[Gustavo Carneiro]

2009/10/29 Faker Moatamri <faker.moatamri@...>

> Mathieu Lacage wrote:
>
>> On Wed, 2009-10-28 at 10:51 +0100, Faker Moatamri wrote:
>>
>>
>>> mathieu/ns-3-simu-old                          unknown    unknown
>>> 10 months ago    If you have any objection to remove any of the above
>>> repositories,
>>> please tell me as soon as possible.
>>>
>>>
>>
>> I am pretty careful in removing uneeded repositories from mathieu/* so,
>> if something is still in there, it means that it has not been merged in
>> another repository yet which means that I would prefer to leave it
>> there.
>>
>>
>>
> Ok we will keep your repository. Should we archive it? It remained
> untouched for nearly one year...
>
> Anyone else has any objection on the removal of repositories from this
> list:

If by remove you mean archive (the way I see now, with a tar.bzw download
option, is ok), then fine by me. Just don't delete the repository files
forever!

>
> ns-3.6-RC4                                            ns-.6-RC3 release
>  <ns-developers@...>    8 days ago   ns-3.6-RC4-ref-traces
>                reference traces for ns-3.6-RC3 release    <
> ns-developers@...>    8 days ago   ns-3.6-RC3
>                    ns-.6-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    12 days
> ago   ns-3.6-RC3-ref-traces                            reference traces for
> ns-3.6-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    12 days ago   ns-3.6-RC2
>                                            ns-.6-RC2 release    <
> ns-developers@...>    13 days ago   ns-3.6-RC2-ref-traces
>                reference traces for ns-3.6-RC2 release    <
> ns-developers@...>    13 days ago   ns-3.6-RC1
>                    ns-.6-RC1 release    <ns-developers@...>    2 weeks
> ago   ns-3.6-RC1-ref-traces                            reference traces for
> ns-3.6-RC1 release    <ns-developers@...>    2 weeks ago
> iamine/ns-3-wimax-to_be_released     wimax module for ns-3 to be merged with
> the main ns-3-dev tree    <amine.ismail@...>    2 months ago
> ns-3-wimax-to_be_released_old2        wimax module for ns-3 to be merged
> with the main ns-3-dev tree    <amine.ismail@...>    2 months
> ago   ns-3-wimax-to_be_released_old          wimax module for ns-3 to be
> merged with the main ns-3-dev tree    <amine.ismail@...>    2
> months ago   ns-3-wimax-dev-old                             unknown
>  unknown    3 months ago   ns-3.4-RC3
>      ns-3.4-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago
> ns-3.4-RC3-ref-traces                            reference traces for
> ns-3.4-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago   ns-3.4-RC2
>                                            ns-3.4-RC2 release    <
> ns-developers@...>    7 months ago   ns-3.4-RC2-ref-traces
>                reference traces for ns-3.4-RC2 release    <
> ns-developers@...>    7 months ago   ns-3.4-RC1
>                      ns-3.4-RC1 release    <ns-developers@...>    7
> months ago   ns-3.4-RC1-ref-traces                            reference
> traces for ns-3.4-RC1 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago
> craigdo/ns-3-test-patches-old                Mercurial Queues patches
> repository backup for ns-3 testing development    <
> craigdo@...>    2 months ago
> ns-3-wimax-old                                     ns-3 wimax development
> tree    <amine.ismail@...>    10 months ago
> vincent/ns-3-ipv6-1st                            NS-3 simulator with IPv6
> support (first chunk).    unknown    11 months ago
>
>> Mathieu
>>
>>
>>
> Best regards
> Faker Moatamri
>
>

--
Gustavo J. A. M. Carneiro
INESC Porto, Telecommunications and Multimedia Unit
"The universe is always one step beyond logic." -- Frank Herbert

[Faker Moatamri]

Gustavo Carneiro wrote:

>
>
> 2009/10/29 Faker Moatamri <faker.moatamri@...
> <mailto:faker.moatamri@...>>
>
>     Mathieu Lacage wrote:
>
>         On Wed, 2009-10-28 at 10:51 +0100, Faker Moatamri wrote:
>          
>
>             mathieu/ns-3-simu-old                          unknown  
>              unknown
>             10 months ago    If you have any objection to remove any
>             of the above repositories,
>             please tell me as soon as possible.
>                
>
>
>         I am pretty careful in removing uneeded repositories from
>         mathieu/* so,
>         if something is still in there, it means that it has not been
>         merged in
>         another repository yet which means that I would prefer to leave it
>         there.
>
>          
>
>     Ok we will keep your repository. Should we archive it? It remained
>     untouched for nearly one year...
>
>     Anyone else has any objection on the removal of repositories from
>     this list:
>
>
> If by remove you mean archive (the way I see now, with a tar.bzw
> download option, is ok), then fine by me. Just don't delete the
> repository files forever!

I mean delete delete, forever, a lot of repositories are just duplicates
and some have been already merged. Also there is no point of keeping 4
release candidates if we have the release itself, right?
Tom archived the ones that he thought might be of interest in the future
and that were never merged. We currently have 89 repos 51 of which
remained untouched for more than 4 months (including RCs).

[Gustavo Carneiro]

2009/10/29 Faker Moatamri <faker.moatamri@...>

> Gustavo Carneiro wrote:
>
>>
>>
>> 2009/10/29 Faker Moatamri <faker.moatamri@... <mailto:
>> faker.moatamri@...>>
>>
>>
>>    Mathieu Lacage wrote:
>>
>>        On Wed, 2009-10-28 at 10:51 +0100, Faker Moatamri wrote:
>>
>>            mathieu/ns-3-simu-old                          unknown
>>       unknown
>>            10 months ago    If you have any objection to remove any
>>            of the above repositories,
>>            please tell me as soon as possible.
>>
>>
>>        I am pretty careful in removing uneeded repositories from
>>        mathieu/* so,
>>        if something is still in there, it means that it has not been
>>        merged in
>>        another repository yet which means that I would prefer to leave it
>>        there.
>>
>>
>>    Ok we will keep your repository. Should we archive it? It remained
>>    untouched for nearly one year...
>>
>>    Anyone else has any objection on the removal of repositories from
>>    this list:
>>
>>
>> If by remove you mean archive (the way I see now, with a tar.bzw download
>> option, is ok), then fine by me. Just don't delete the repository files
>> forever!
>>
> I mean delete delete, forever, a lot of repositories are just duplicates
> and some have been already merged. Also there is no point of keeping 4
> release candidates if we have the release itself, right?
> Tom archived the ones that he thought might be of interest in the future
> and that were never merged. We currently have 89 repos 51 of which remained
> untouched for more than 4 months (including RCs).
>

Some of the repos have not been merged and contain the start of some useful
work.  For instance, gjc/ns-3-wifi-scanning is incomplete, but if someone
had time and inclination to finish the work, they could conceivably learn
something from my old repository, maybe even copy some code.  It's a pity to
just obliterate it forever.

If you keep around 100 repos in tar.bz2 format, at 10 MB each, that adds to
1GB.  Hardly difficult with today's hard disk capacities.  So I don't
understand why so anxious to delete everything...

If a branch was not merged into ns-3-dev, I think you should keep it around
somehow, for at least a few years.

--
Gustavo J. A. M. Carneiro
INESC Porto, Telecommunications and Multimedia Unit
"The universe is always one step beyond logic." -- Frank Herbert

[Faker Moatamri]

Gustavo Carneiro wrote:

>
>
> 2009/10/29 Faker Moatamri <faker.moatamri@...
> <mailto:faker.moatamri@...>>
>
>
>
>         If by remove you mean archive (the way I see now, with a
>         tar.bzw download option, is ok), then fine by me. Just don't
>         delete the repository files forever!
>
>     I mean delete delete, forever, a lot of repositories are just
>     duplicates and some have been already merged. Also there is no
>     point of keeping 4 release candidates if we have the release
>     itself, right?
>     Tom archived the ones that he thought might be of interest in the
>     future and that were never merged. We currently have 89 repos 51
>     of which remained untouched for more than 4 months (including RCs).
>
>
> Some of the repos have not been merged and contain the start of some
> useful work.  For instance, gjc/ns-3-wifi-scanning is incomplete, but
> if someone had time and inclination to finish the work, they could
> conceivably learn something from my old repository, maybe even copy
> some code.  It's a pity to just obliterate it forever.

Those won't be deleted or at least they will be archived. That's why I'm
asking permission from the owners of the repos before deleting. I need
to make sure it is really useless.
>
> If you keep around 100 repos in tar.bz2 format, at 10 MB each, that
> adds to 1GB.  Hardly difficult with today's hard disk capacities.  So
> I don't understand why so anxious to delete everything...
Yes of course, it never has been a matter of disk space. Actually, I'm
not planning to delete everything, and that's why I'm asking people if I
can delete before actually deleting. I will delete *only 100% useless
repos*, the others we will archive them or we will keep them in the
repo. Is that ok with you?

If you still think that we should systematically archive all the deleted
repos, I have no problem with that. It's just that I find it useless in
the only case that we are 100% that the repo has no interest.
>
> If a branch was not merged into ns-3-dev, I think you should keep it
> around somehow, for at least a few years.
Yes sure, that's what Tom did and what I will do. Actually I think that
if it is less than one year old, I will leave it in the repo, if it is
older that that, it will go to Tom's archive in the wiki page.
>
> --
> Gustavo J. A. M. Carneiro
> INESC Porto, Telecommunications and Multimedia Unit
> "The universe is always one step beyond logic." -- Frank Herbert
Best regard,
Faker Moatamri

[Gustavo Carneiro]

2009/10/29 Faker Moatamri <faker.moatamri@...>

> Gustavo Carneiro wrote:
>
>>
>>
>> 2009/10/29 Faker Moatamri <faker.moatamri@... <mailto:
>> faker.moatamri@...>>
>>
>>
>>
>>        If by remove you mean archive (the way I see now, with a
>>        tar.bzw download option, is ok), then fine by me. Just don't
>>        delete the repository files forever!
>>
>>    I mean delete delete, forever, a lot of repositories are just
>>    duplicates and some have been already merged. Also there is no
>>    point of keeping 4 release candidates if we have the release
>>    itself, right?
>>    Tom archived the ones that he thought might be of interest in the
>>    future and that were never merged. We currently have 89 repos 51
>>    of which remained untouched for more than 4 months (including RCs).
>>
>>
>> Some of the repos have not been merged and contain the start of some
>> useful work.  For instance, gjc/ns-3-wifi-scanning is incomplete, but if
>> someone had time and inclination to finish the work, they could conceivably
>> learn something from my old repository, maybe even copy some code.  It's a
>> pity to just obliterate it forever.
>>
> Those won't be deleted or at least they will be archived. That's why I'm
> asking permission from the owners of the repos before deleting. I need to
> make sure it is really useless.

OK, in that case. from my repos you can really delete (since wifi-scanning
seems to be already moved to the wiki as tar.bz2):

gjc/ns-3-allinone <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-allinone/>
gjc/ns-3-tap-netdevice <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-tap-netdevice/>
gjc/ns-3-waf1.5 <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-waf1.5/>
gjc/ns-3-waf154 <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-waf154/>
gjc/ns-3-dev-flowmon <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-dev-flowmon/>

You should keep for a long time:
 gjc/ns-3-flowmon <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-flowmon/>   (some
benchmark scripts in there that are not ported to ns-3-dev, so it's not
really 100% merged)

You should definitely keep, forever until further notice:
gjc/ns-3-pyviz <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-pyviz/>   (lack of time to
work on this, but I think this is a cool project)


Thanks,

--
Gustavo J. A. M. Carneiro
INESC Porto, Telecommunications and Multimedia Unit
"The universe is always one step beyond logic." -- Frank Herbert

[craigdo]

Hi Faker,

Please do not delete any repos under craigdo.  It is clean with the exception of a branch useful to folks running ns-3 on ORBIT (and required by a HOWTO).

Regards,

-- Craig

[Faker Moatamri]

ns-3.6-RC4                                            ns-.6-RC3
release    <ns-developers@...>    8 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC4-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.6-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    8 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC3                                            ns-.6-RC3
release    <ns-developers@...>    12 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC3-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.6-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    12 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC2                                            ns-.6-RC2
release    <ns-developers@...>    13 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC2-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.6-RC2 release    <ns-developers@...>    13 days ago  
ns-3.6-RC1                                            ns-.6-RC1
release    <ns-developers@...>    2 weeks ago  
ns-3.6-RC1-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.6-RC1 release    <ns-developers@...>    2 weeks ago      
iamine/ns-3-wimax-to_be_released     wimax module for ns-3 to be merged
with the main ns-3-dev tree    <amine.ismail@...>    2
months ago  
ns-3-wimax-to_be_released_old2        wimax module for ns-3 to be merged
with the main ns-3-dev tree    <amine.ismail@...>    2
months ago  
ns-3-wimax-to_be_released_old          wimax module for ns-3 to be
merged with the main ns-3-dev tree    <amine.ismail@...>    
2 months ago  
ns-3-wimax-dev-old                             unknown    unknown    3
months ago  
ns-3.4-RC3                                            ns-3.4-RC3
release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC3-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.4-RC3 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC2                                            ns-3.4-RC2
release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC2-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.4-RC2 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC1                                            ns-3.4-RC1
release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3.4-RC1-ref-traces                            reference traces for
ns-3.4-RC1 release    <ns-developers@...>    7 months ago  
ns-3-wimax-old                                     ns-3 wimax
development tree    <amine.ismail@...>    10 months ago  
vincent/ns-3-ipv6-1st                            NS-3 simulator with
IPv6 support (first chunk).    unknown    11 months ago
> gjc/ns-3-allinone <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-allinone/>
> gjc/ns-3-tap-netdevice <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-tap-netdevice/>
> gjc/ns-3-waf1.5 <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-waf1.5/>
> gjc/ns-3-waf154 <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-waf154/>
> gjc/ns-3-dev-flowmon <http://code.nsnam.org/gjc/ns-3-dev-flowmon/>
>
Ok done.

Now we need to know about those repos, which ones we should
keep/archive/delete:

guillaume/ns-3-multithreading                                unknown    
unknown    2 months ago  
guillaume/ns-3-multithreading-new                        unknown    
unknown    2 months ago  
guillaume/ns-3-multithreading-new/.hg/patches    unknown    unknown    2
months ago  
guillaume/ns-3-multithreading-old                          ns-3
multithreaded simulator implementation    Guillaume Seguin
<guillaume.seguin@...>    3 months ago  
guillaume/ns-3-multithreading/.hg/patches            unknown    
unknown    2 months ago  

raj/ns-3-dev                                                            
   unknown    unknown    7 months ago  
raj/ns-3-netanim                                                        
unknown    unknown    7 months ago  
raj/ns-3-rng-changes                                                  
unknown    unknown    8 months ago  
raj/ns-3-rng-changes-ref-traces                                  
unknown    unknown    8 months ago  
raj/ns-3-tcp                                                            
    unknown    unknown    7 months ago  
raj/ns-3-tcp-ref-traces                                                
unknown    unknown    7 months ago  

Thanks for your cooperation :-)
Faker Moatamri

[Faker Moatamri]

George Riley wrote:
> I would say that anything belonging to "raj" can be removed, assuming
> we do
> have a backup somewhere.
>
Thanks george, I will remove them on friday 10 am GMT+1, if no one has
objection on that.
Mathieu, Guillaume what about the repositories under guillaume? What is
to keep/archive/delete?
Best regards
Faker Moatamri

[Guillaume Seguin]

On 04 nov. 2009 à 18:53:15 (+0100), Faker Moatamri wrote :
> Mathieu, Guillaume what about the repositories under guillaume? What is  
> to keep/archive/delete?

I think you can archive ns-3-multithreading-old and delete
ns-3-multithreading-new. I also think that ns-3-multithreading is not up to
date, I'll check asap.

Guillaume

[Faker Moatamri]

Guillaume Seguin wrote:
>
> I think you can archive ns-3-multithreading-old and delete
> ns-3-multithreading-new. I also think that ns-3-multithreading is not up to
> date, I'll check asap.
>
> Guillaume
>  
Hi all, Hi Guillaume,
As promised, I removed raj/ repositories
Removed ns-3-multithreading-new
I will leave ns-3-multithreading-old in the repositories until it got
old enough to be moved to archive, unless you are sure that no one will
use it.
For ns-3-multithreading I will wait until you tell me if it is out of
date or not.
Best regards
Faker Moatamri